A few weeks back (ed. note: this is because I sat on this for a while - sorry), I pulled off this little one-two punch making fun of Chuck Knoblauch.
I was proud of the first comment and smitten with the follow-up. The commentariat seemed to like it as well. Then, I looked at Raysism’s “inside softball” reply and cobra’s comment on this blog and realized I’d done it again. I’d made a Deadspin-only, insiderbaseball type comment.
What I do in these types of situations is DM the comment ninja. I figure it’s always better to stay ahead of trouble. The ninja was kind – the person or persons behind the account is generally fair if you just ask - but did say that, although the comment was exclusive by its nature, it played okay on its own and thus would stay up. Not surprisingly, the ninja also provided me with some light admonishment that I clean up my act and some encouraging words about my commenting.
I’d like to use this situation to think a bit about humor. Prior to MBA, this site, and Streetcheese, I’d never considered analyzing humor before*, so my apologies if this sounds like a poorly constructed rip job.
I believe that a portion (though not all, certainly) of humor is exclusive by nature. Any type of humor based on shared experience will necessarily exclude those people that didn’t share in the experience. For example, the laziest “quasi-acceptable” Deadspin comment has been the movie/TV show reference. Many of us got our start like that. Say what you want about the guy, but Bill Simmons built a cottage industry predicated on this style of humor. But if you didn’t see the movie or TV show? It doesn’t work at all, which is why Bill doesn’t play nearly as well to the under-20 crowd. Basically, you have no point of reference, Donny.
Scientists have hypothesized that the primary function of humor is to bridge connections with other humans, a human version of sniffing each other’s asses. As such, I’d venture to say this style of humor works because it is exclusive. Part of “getting the joke” is feeling important/ clever/serendipitous enough to have been a part of the original experience that generated the joke in the first place. It’s satisfying and rewarding to “get” a joke like this.
My philosophy in Deadspin commenting has always been (though I didn’t realize it until Sean Newell articulated it on MBA) “desperately seeking the +1.” For whatever reason, the approval of some random-ass folks on the internet is really fucking important to me. I have no clue why this is.
The original Commentariat Manifesto states simply “do not be unfunny.” As such, I know I consciously attempted to tailor my humor to those starred folks who would approve and, ultimately, star me. Those were the people I was trying to emulate. That was the crowd I was trying to join. I wanted to “get” the jokes that everyone else was “getting.” (WTF is “Run you stupid fucking dinosaur, run!”?) At the time, I didn’t realize how ingrained this humor customization would become.
The original Commentariat Manifesto states simply “do not be unfunny.” As such, I know I consciously attempted to tailor my humor to those starred folks who would approve and, ultimately, star me. Those were the people I was trying to emulate. That was the crowd I was trying to join. I wanted to “get” the jokes that everyone else was “getting.” (WTF is “Run you stupid fucking dinosaur, run!”?) At the time, I didn’t realize how ingrained this humor customization would become.
The game, though, has changed a bit in recent months as Gawker has sought to be more inclusive of commenters and eliminate insider-y meme threads. Garnering +1s from the commentariat doesn’t cut it anymore. The comment ninja has been clear as a bell on this and it’s me that hasn’t adapted. I’m also not making a value judgment on this shift in commenting policy. It’s their site, and commenting there is a privilege. One that I’m glad I have and enjoy doing.
The Knoblauch twofer was an interesting experience, for me anyhow, because when I made the second comment I didn’t think twice about it being exclusive. My naiveté was that “of course everyone saw the first comment.” After I posted the comment and DMed with the ninja, my only thought was, “How stupid can I be?” So, clearly, I need to not make comments like that.
Thus, here’s what I was thinking: with this site and with twitter, the commenters currently possess enough infrastructure to help morans like me out. Seriously, I’d prefer not to get banned because I’m idiot. If I’m going to get banned, I’d like it to be because I made some amazing comment that can never be replicated ever again and I will be enshrined in the DSHOF.
In some sense, this already exists. Many said on Twitter that I shouldn’t have called out the “amazing awanus” guy in the comment section. I should’ve listened. I will now.
* Except for, in High School, the guy in the seat next to me was failing English class. On one test, I’d scored in the 80’s on one test and he had scored below 10. Then, he said to me, “Getting a 0 on a test isn’t funny, but getting 3? Now that’s funny.” I will never forget that.
* Except for, in High School, the guy in the seat next to me was failing English class. On one test, I’d scored in the 80’s on one test and he had scored below 10. Then, he said to me, “Getting a 0 on a test isn’t funny, but getting 3? Now that’s funny.” I will never forget that.
MKM > RMJ=H