Showing posts with label #mildlyunhingedletterstoeditor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #mildlyunhingedletterstoeditor. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Mildly Unhinged Letters to the Editor: RMJ=H Edition

Welcome back to our semi-regular feature spotlighting your idiotic meaningless thoughts that do not represent the views of this balog or those of our spiritual founder and superior commenter, MKM.  Tonight, our guest is comment of the year co-finalist, RMJ=H, the guy you know for making that one really funny comment, and then like 600 shitty inside baseball jokes.  No, not Raysism.  The other one.  Without further ado, I give you, RMJ=H.


A few weeks back (ed. note: this is because I sat on this for a while - sorry), I pulled off this little one-two punch making fun of Chuck Knoblauch.

I was proud of the first comment and smitten with the follow-up.  The commentariat seemed to like it as well.  Then, I looked at Raysism’s “inside softball” reply and cobra’s comment on this blog and realized I’d done it again.  I’d made a Deadspin-only, insiderbaseball type comment.

What I do in these types of situations is DM the comment ninja.  I figure it’s always better to stay ahead of trouble.  The ninja was kind – the person or persons behind the account is generally fair if you just ask - but did say that, although the comment was exclusive by its nature, it played okay on its own and thus would stay up.  Not surprisingly, the ninja also provided me with some light admonishment that I clean up my act and some encouraging words about my commenting.

I’d like to use this situation to think a bit about humor.  Prior to MBA, this site, and Streetcheese, I’d never considered analyzing humor before*, so my apologies if this sounds like a poorly constructed rip job.

I believe that a portion (though not all, certainly) of humor is exclusive by nature.  Any type of humor based on shared experience will necessarily exclude those people that didn’t share in the experience.  For example, the laziest “quasi-acceptable” Deadspin comment has been the movie/TV show reference.  Many of us got our start like that.  Say what you want about the guy, but Bill Simmons built a cottage industry predicated on this style of humor.  But if you didn’t see the movie or TV show? It doesn’t work at all, which is why Bill doesn’t play nearly as well to the under-20 crowd.  Basically, you have no point of reference, Donny.

Scientists have hypothesized that the primary function of humor is to bridge connections with other humans, a human version of sniffing each other’s asses.  As such, I’d venture to say this style of humor works because it is exclusive.  Part of “getting the joke” is feeling important/ clever/serendipitous enough to have been a part of the original experience that generated the joke in the first place.  It’s satisfying and rewarding to “get” a joke like this.

My philosophy in Deadspin commenting has always been (though I didn’t realize it until Sean Newell articulated it on MBA) “desperately seeking the +1.”  For whatever reason, the approval of some random-ass folks on the internet is really fucking important to me.  I have no clue why this is.  
The original Commentariat Manifesto states simply “do not be unfunny.”  As such, I know I consciously attempted to tailor my humor to those starred folks who would approve and, ultimately, star me.  Those were the people I was trying to emulate.  That was the crowd I was trying to join.  I wanted to “get” the jokes that everyone else was “getting.” (WTF is “Run you stupid fucking dinosaur, run!”?) At the time, I didn’t realize how ingrained this humor customization would become.

The game, though, has changed a bit in recent months as Gawker has sought to be more inclusive of commenters and eliminate insider-y meme threads.  Garnering +1s from the commentariat doesn’t cut it anymore.  The comment ninja has been clear as a bell on this and it’s me that hasn’t adapted.  I’m also not making a value judgment on this shift in commenting policy.  It’s their site, and commenting there is a privilege.  One that I’m glad I have and enjoy doing.

The Knoblauch twofer was an interesting experience, for me anyhow, because when I made the second comment I didn’t think twice about it being exclusive. My naiveté was that “of course everyone saw the first comment.”   After I posted the comment and DMed with the ninja, my only thought was, “How stupid can I be?” So, clearly, I need to not make comments like that.

Thus, here’s what I was thinking: with this site and with twitter, the commenters currently possess enough infrastructure to help morans like me out.  Seriously, I’d prefer not to get banned because I’m idiot.  If I’m going to get banned, I’d like it to be because I made some amazing comment that can never be replicated ever again and I will be enshrined in the DSHOF.

In some sense, this already exists. Many said on Twitter that I shouldn’t have called out the “amazing awanus” guy in the comment section.  I should’ve listened.  I will now.

* Except for, in High School, the guy in the seat next to me was failing English class.  On one test, I’d scored in the 80’s on one test and he had scored below 10.  Then, he said to me, “Getting a 0 on a test isn’t funny, but getting 3? Now that’s funny.” I will never forget that.



MKM > RMJ=H

Monday, January 16, 2012

Mildly Unhinged Letters to The Editor (Gamboa Constrictor edition)

Gamboa Constrictor, Deadspin's own Harry Houdini, recently got in touch about writing a tribute to his commenting mentor, MKM.  What I received instead was a grammatically-impeccable tribute to the importance of staying on all your prescription medications.  I'm posting it anyway, because it is well done, and also so the police know where to look when this blog inexplicably goes silent in a few days...

GAMBOA, NOOOOOOOOO........

First of all, I have to say it is an absolute honor and privilege to be asked to take the dais and provide my own special tribute to the one and only MarkKelsosMigraine. So to get a little "housekeeping" out of the way up front, I want to give a quick thanks to IronMikeGallego for the opportunity to do so.

Speaking of IronMike, I'll never forget the first time we met, mainly because I never even formed a memory of it. But it didn't take long for me to realize that this guy was one to watch. You'd be hard-pressed to come up with someone so quick to ascend to the pantheon of above-average metalurgically-named commenters, joining titanic legends such as BronzeHammer, Tinphastic, LeadNed, and, of course, Nickly. As if that weren't enough, few could argue that IronMike has since firmly entrenched himself on the list of Deadspin's top 50 funniest commenters with light-hitting infielder-themed handles, somewhere between WhynotstartYunieveryday and the legendary Walt Weiss' Fupa. Next stop, Starville, indeed.  

It is no coincidence that IronMike adopted the persona of a scrappy utility player, because he treats every thread like excessive practice. Always the /FIRST! to show up and the last to leave. I can't remember the last time he didn't comment on a post, which is why I keep it bookmarked. Seriously, I haven't seen a guy put in so much work for a +1 since the last time Jay Mariotti was invited to a wedding. But all the hard work has finally paid off, now that IronMike has arguably reinvented the genre of parody blogs of other people's parody blogs of other people's parody blogs. It certainly should come as no surprise to all 12 of his followers that he has pioneered this revolutionary brand of comedy. Followers with such prestigious names as Goulet, Alan Whickers, and, of course, Nickly.

As IronMike has evolved, so has Deadspin at large. Most would say that he is almost single-handedly responsible for the "new Deadspin"'s much-needed shift away from funny comments and towards long, rambling, "intelligent" discourse. In fact, his comments would indicate that he saw it coming long before anyone else. This transition has allowed IronMike to truly shine by consistently initiating (and then dominating) "discussions" on such diverse topics as boxing, liking boxing, masturbating to boxing, and how to masturbate while wearing boxing gloves. As far as articulate authorities on the "Sweet Science" go, IronMike is unquestionably up there among the most eloquent, right alongside golden-voiced icons like Larry Merchant, Evander Holyfield, Teddy Atlas, and, of course, Nickly. (Seriously, that dude's a huge fight fan.) 

So I may not remember meeting IronMike, but I certainly won't forget him.  And I don't think anyone else will, either. And not just because of his constant presence or his trademark "We also would have accepted"/"So-and-so approves" replies.  For it is very rare for a commenter to come along and change the rules of Deadspin. IronMike not only changed the rules, but he changed THE rule, as in Rule #1 in the Commentist Manifesto. Now that's impressive. 

Congratulations, IronMike. In a world of highly-distinguished commenters, YuDaMan.

Oh, and in closing, I like those two jokes MarkKelsosMigraine has been making for the last 5 years. Hilarious.

MKM > Gamboa Constrictor

Sunday, January 15, 2012

Mildly Unhinged Letters to the Editor (Same Sad Echo edition)

Same Sad Echo, Deadspin's leading Buzz Killington impressionist and sub-MKM commenter, was the subject of one of our profiles this morning.  Based upon an impassioned and needlessly prolix response on twitter (which he probably lifted directly from Sharting), he has been given the opportunity to post a rebuttal.  Oddly enough, it's really long and especially unfunny.  Enjoy?


In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. He then created the sky, and day and night and trees and animals. He was on an awesome tear, but I’m guessing he got distracted by something shiny, because he forgot to create professional boxing and hip-hop. Which was kind of a shame, because IronMikeGallego has been bored stiff for the last six thousand years.
[crickets]
Ha ha. Yes, making fun of IMG for being old is a bit of a meme, isn’t it? Like UweBullocks [ed: sic; sick?]  killing people in his basement, or Phintastic and his Sneetch-like star problems, or Hatey McLife being funny.
Did you know that it only took IMG two comments to get his star? It’s true. One comment to get approved, and his star on the next. That must be a record. You know what else is a record? Pocketful of Kryptonite by the Spin Doctors. That record sold over five million copies. Records don’t mean shit.
IMG has done a nice job with this little blog, cleverly lampooning other commenters. But where, one asks, does IMG fit into the equation? How can we explain it? Let’s take it frame-by-frame it, shall we?
In 1984 a triumph of cinema was created. This masterpiece is better known as The Karate Kid. There are some interesting parallels to be drawn here. Clearly, comment_ninja is Mr. Miyagi (Noriyuki “Pat” Morita). Sure, he may snap a neck or two, but ultimately he’s using his powers for good. Daniel (Ralph Macchio) represents none of us and all of us at the same time; his transformation from scrawny-necked geek to a scrawny-necked geek who wins a karate tournament is a similar journey to any commenter who starts out pink, turns gray, and gets a star. We had to do it without a kick-ass theme song, so I’d say we’re much tougher.
Eddie Murray Sparkles is Ali (Elizabeth Shue), for obvious reasons.
But we need to dig a little deeper to get to the heart of the matter. Enter, if you dare, into the Cobra Kai dojo. MKM, by virtue of being the subject of this blog, is the dastardly sensei. Now, I don’t think MKM could punch his way out of a My Fair Lady handbill, and I’ve yet to hear him make a racist remark about any southeast Asians, but this is taking longer than I expected so let’s move on.
Clearly, IMG lacks the leadership, charisma or strong jawline to be Johnny (William Zabka). In addition, IMG would have no problem taking out the knee of an opponent, either that of a fellow competitor or an old lady in front of him at the Safeway who is paying for her cat food with a check, and complaining that her children never call her any more, oh and did you know her bursitis is acting up and she doesn’t understand Medicare Part and why do kids wear their pants so low.
So who’s left? Jerry? Oh, you’re not sure who Jerry is? He’s the tall, thin guy. Short haircut. Doesn’t make it very far in the tourney, and seems a bit conflicted about his role in the ongoing bullying of Daniel. Doesn’t get a lot of lines. If you think I’m gonna call him “the black guy” you’re sorely mistaken you hood-wearing racists.
Which leaves us Dutch. You remember Dutch, with his stupid haircut and his “get him a body bag” sensibilities. Dutch, who, like IMG…you know, the analogies are falling apart here a bit. I’m kinda surprised you made it this far, actually. Do you really have nothing better to do on a Sunday? God that’s depressing. I mean, IMG is paying me a hundred bucks to write this, so I’ve got good reason to be here. What’s your excuse? Your “girlfriend” go back to visit her family in the Niagara Falls region? Staying in to catch up on the new Doctor Who? Pinned under your garage door while rats chew your ears? God you nerds make me sick.
So anyway, IMG. He’s ok, I guess. Whatever.


Oh, that's so funny, dude!  +1!!1!

MKM > Tebow as a Deadspin Commenter > Same Sad Echo